Valuation December 2016: Ciputra Development (CTRA.JK)

Three property companies under Ciputra brand are going to do a merger on December 23rd, 2016. Two subsidiaries of CTRA, CTRP and CTRS, are going to be merged into CTRA. The merger use share swap with the ratio of 2.13x for CTRS and 0.54x for CTRP. In this valuation I’m not going to discuss the effect of the merger itself, but rather the valuation of CTRA alone.

Download the excel file containing full valuation: ctra-3q16

screen-shot-2016-12-16-at-3-50-01-pm

This year CTRA revenue is declining due to the slowdown in credit and demand in the property sector, however the impact of successful Tax Amnesty and increasing middle class of Indonesian demographic is expected to drive growth for the next few years. In my valuation using Free Cash Flow to Firm (FCFF) method, it results in fair value of Rp 2200/share, a  60% upside from Friday, December 16th 2016 price of Rp 1370/share.

screen-shot-2016-12-16-at-3-50-18-pm

I compare the result from FCFF method to historical sector PE, PS, and PBV ratio pictured below. Trailing PE is currently at the 5-years high level due to the declining profits of many property companies this year, but it is expected to reverse next year, hence the valuation may be justified. Using the historical sector PBV ratio, it results in fair value of Rp 2140/share, similar to the value derived from FCFF method.

Screen Shot 2016-12-16 at 4.08.10 PM.png

In summary, I believe CTRA valuation is attractive currently, and with the good prospect of the merger, I recommend BUY for CTRA with TP Rp 2200/share.

However, instead of buying the CTRA stock directly, there is an alternative to it. You could buy CTRS and CTRP for a bargain price. On Friday, below is the price of each stock intraday on December 16th 2016:

CTRA = 1370

CTRP = 680

CTRS = 2720

The merger use share swap with the ratio of 2.13x for CTRS and 0.54x for CTRP. Therefore the equivalent value of each stock (if CTRA = 1370) using no-arbitrage rule is:

CTRA= 1370

CTRP = 1370 x 0.54 = 740 (8.8% discount)

CTRS = 1370 x 2.13 = 2920 (7.4% discount)

Therefore, assuming the merger is closed, CTRP provides the greatest value to stockholder, an upside of 8.8% + 60.09% = 68.89%. But acquiring a big lot of CTRP and CTRS prove to be difficult due to the thin liquidity of each stock compared to CTRA.

Published by Journeyman

A global macro analyst with over four years experience in the financial market, the author began his career as an equity analyst before transitioning to macro research focusing on Emerging Markets at a well-known independent research firm. He read voraciously, spending most of his free time following The Economist magazine and reading topics on finance and self-improvement. When off duty, he works part-time for Getty Images, taking pictures from all over the globe. To date, he has over 1200 pictures over 35 countries being sold through the company.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: